Israel Police Criticized for "Under-policing" Crime, "Over-policing" Citizens

Arab citizens in Israel feel the police fail to provide basic personal security, while simultaneously experiencing excessive force and humiliation when law enforcement does engage. This paradox of "under-policing" and "over-policing" is highlighted by recent incidents, such as police intervention at a wedding that turned a joyous occasion into one of fear and degradation. The article argues that while the police must enforce the law, the manner of enforcement is crucial, emphasizing proportionality and a respectful approach to citizens.

The piece contends that the police's actions are influenced by a political climate that glorifies force and "governability," blurring the lines between professional law enforcement and displays of power. It stresses that while a minister can set policy, the police must remain a professional and state-oriented body, focused on protecting the public rather than creating content for social media.

This issue is particularly acute for the Arab community due to an existing deep-seated trust deficit. The article posits that trust is built through daily interactions, not campaigns, and questions how citizens can trust a police force perceived as ineffective against crime but swift and forceful against civilian events. This situation is seen as a breach of the social contract, where the state is expected to protect its citizens, not exert excessive power against them.

Beyond policing, the article advocates for a broader policy addressing the needs of Arab youth, including opportunities in education, employment, and social mobility. It references government decision 550 and the State Comptroller's reports, which emphasize the importance of integrating Arab youth into the economy and academia to reduce gaps and address social issues, including crime. True "governability," it argues, is about the state ensuring citizens feel supported, not just demonstrating force.

The author concludes that the Arab community needs a different kind of policing and a different relationship with the state: more protection and less force, more crime-solving and less humiliation, and more focus on fighting organized crime rather than viewing Arab citizens as potential threats. Simultaneously, increased opportunities in employment, education, and shared spaces are needed to foster a sense of belonging and equal citizenship.